Comparing the right charging cards is complex. The market is dominated by dozens of providers with variable pricing structures: from fixed subscription fees to flexible kWh prices with high starting rates. Your ideal charging card depends on your charging habits. An efficient choice avoids unnecessary costs and guarantees coverage. This overview structures the market, analyzes the costs and network, and helps you select the best card.
Why this topic is important: Cost savings and frictionless charging
The charging card is the gateway to the public network and determines the variable costs of electric driving.
-
Avoiding 'Pass Chaos': Many EV drivers have multiple passes to guarantee coverage at all times. This is inefficient. This article helps reduce the number of passes to one or two optimal ones.
-
Transparency in Roaming: The cost structure when using a charging station from a different operator than your card provider (roaming) is often opaque and leads to unexpectedly high bills.
-
Hardware Connection: The charging card and the appropriate Type 2 charging cable are the two physical necessities for every public charging session. A reliable card is just as important as high-quality hardware.
How does Charging Pass Comparison work in practice: Tariff models
The charging card market can be broadly divided into three pricing models. Your choice should be based on these:
1. Model A: The All-in-one Pass (Subscription)
-
Features: Fixed monthly fees (€3-€10). In return, you pay lower, often fixed, charging card fees per kWh at almost all public charging stations, regardless of operator (no or low roaming charges).
-
Ideal for: Frequent public chargers (more than 10-15 charging sessions per month) and business drivers looking for transparency and simplicity in billing.
2. Model B: The Pay-per-use Pass (Free)
-
Features: No fixed monthly fees. You pay a small setup fee (€0.30 - €0.70) per charging session, plus the charging station operator's (CPO) variable kWh rate. Roaming costs are often higher and are charged per minute or per kWh.
-
Ideal for: Occasional public chargers (private individuals who mainly charge at home, but want the card as a backup), or the user who is looking for the best charging card without a subscription .
3. Model C: The Operator-bound Pass
-
Features: A card issued by the charging station owner (e.g., an energy company). You pay the lowest rate at their own stations, but roaming charges with other networks are very high.
-
Ideal for: Users who always charge at their regular work or home location with one specific charging station operator.
Selection advice or comparison: Your charging profile is decisive
Your charging behavior is the only variable that should influence your choice.
-
The 'Home Charger' (Backup): Choose the best charging card without a subscription (Model B). You only pay when you actually use the card. The higher roaming charges are justified because the frequency is low. Be sure to bring a charging cable bag and locks to protect the cable during these sessions.
-
The "On-the-Go Charger" (Commuter): Choose a subscription (Model A). The fixed monthly costs are more than offset by the lower and predictable rates on the major network.
-
The 'Border Pusher' (NL/BE): Look for a provider with a strong focus on international coverage and low roaming charges in popular transit countries. Specifically ask for a charging card with coverage in Belgium or Germany if you travel there regularly.
Crucial Note: Don't just focus on the lowest initial cost. Compare the total cost (initial rate + kWh price from the CPO + roaming fees from the card provider). These last two factors provide the biggest surprises.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between a charging card with and without a subscription?
A subscription-based charging card (Model A) requires a fixed monthly payment in exchange for lower, predictable charging rates per kWh and low/no roaming charges. A subscription-based card (Model B) is free in its basic form, but you pay a connection fee per session plus the higher, variable rates of the charging station operator (CPO), including higher roaming charges.
How do I avoid unexpectedly high roaming costs abroad?
You can avoid unexpectedly high roaming charges by choosing a charging card from a provider that explicitly guarantees fixed, low rates in the countries where you frequently charge. Use the card provider's app to check the rates at the specific charging station in advance . Note: Roaming may also apply within the Netherlands if you charge at a station from a competing provider.
Which charging card has the best coverage in the Netherlands and Belgium?
There's no single "best" pass, but the best coverage is offered by providers that are members of the major roaming networks. Look for passes that demonstrate a high degree of interoperability. Large, national providers generally have the best coverage in both the Netherlands and Belgium, but check this with their coverage map.
In summary:
Comparing the market for charging cards is primarily a choice between cost predictability (subscription) and flexibility (no subscription). Determine your charging profile: frequent chargers will choose the predictable low kWh rates of a subscription. Backup chargers will opt for a free card. Make sure you have reliable hardware in addition to the card. Compare providers' rates now and ensure you have a suitable charging cable to charge immediately.
